Post by Bingbing Fan on Nov 11, 2011 21:11:44 GMT -5
Hey Girls..
Welcome to your Third Judging session. I don't waste any more time since I knew a lot of you dying to find out the result..
Let see your photo this week
Amanda: I'm not really fond of either of these. The pose on the cover is really awkward to the point that it looks painful, and there's too much going on around you. The spread looks lower-quality and you come across as a cyborg. I really don't know how good your chances are this week given these
BB: I really like the Cover.. I think you look energetic.. Yes of course I want some Choco Neck from you but for me, the styling in this Cover is good enough. I love the make up, hairstyles and even the dress though we can't see it completely. I'm not really excited with the spread. I love your face but the styling didn't work for me.
Matt: I love the cover. The smile and everything about it. I don't like the spread it doesnt look model like at all. But i know you'll do well.
Nicki: I quite enjoy the poses of both, but not the layout of either.
Karen: I like the magazine cover. It's very fresh and cute, even if the pose is a tad awkward. The spread, however, is a bit sci-fi and the photo quality is a little too blurry for my tastes. Overall, I'm fairly impressed.
BB: I think your cover is so beautiful. Very alive and once again your lips; really sexy and beautiful. And your spread, i'm not sure about this one. Your eyes were close and the angle is a little bit off. Even the pose a little bit awkward for me.
Amanda: That cover is very memorable but like last time too zoomed in. Your spread is iffy given the pose and the arm and the expression...
Matt: I like both of these. The Cover is very different and very beautiful. The spread is a bit plan but very model like.
Nicki: I absolutely LOVE the cover, but the spread is mediocre at best.
Karen: I'm pretty much in the same boat as everybody else. I think that the cover is beautiful, and very artistic, but the pose in the spread really doesn't do you any favors and hides your face, which is definitely a no-no.
Amanda: The magazine cover is good, but that dress looks to be a bit too much for me and your expression is a bit too vacant. The spread seems grainy, but after that it's pretty good. I can't find anything wrong with it, but I can't find anything that sticks out to me, either. Overall, these two are just okay.
BB: The styling for the Cover one a little bit messy.. Look 'heavy' on you but I love the whole concept. You face should be more stronger. I knew you can do better than this. As for the Spread, I think it is a good shot. You look very flirty and innocent at the same time. I love the concept.
Matt: The cover = beautiful but the only thing i dont like is your mouth it's shaped weird but other than that its great. The spread is very simple and i like that. I love the hair and the pose.
Nicki: I'm not a huge fan of the cover because you look spaced out. I do like the spread, though. Good job on that! \
Karen: It's true, you do look kind of bored in the cover, but everything else in the photo is simply astounding.
The spread, ech, I hate the quality. In fact, I've hated on the quality of every spread this round, so I'm just going to stop saying that, because apparently this is just a universal thing with spreads or something. Anyway, the pose is good, but the facial expression definitely puts me in the mind of zombies, and that's never a good thing unless you're modelling for a Halloween photoshoot.
Amanda: I'm not completely sure about either of them. The cover is kind of plain and generic, and your expression needs work. This is the kind of cover I wouldn't be interested to find out who is on it, since it's so unmemorable and not very striking, and it's also a bit cluttered. I do like your hair, though.
The spread is definitely something very, very different, and since it's a risk it's more apt to win points with me. I again like your hair, but you almost look like a mime in a clown's outfit. Those socks are kind of iffy, and it just seems weird in general. I love the setting though, as it's like you're telling a story, showing emotion. I like it, but don't love it since it's just kind of weird for me. I do want you to stay around, though, so good luck and hope you do
BB: You were lucky this isn't a stress week, so I don't mind the extension. As for the Cover, I really like it. I think you look very soft, sweet and vulnerable. As for the spread, your look was really different than the Cover one, In this one, you are edgier and bolder. The styling kinda off to me.. The combination didn't work for me, but overall you did good
Matt: Not a fan of the cover. Your face looks kind of dead and tired. The Spread i like a lot. It's very artistic and it's something that catches my eye and will be something I remember.
Nicki: Not a fan of the cover either, but the spread is very cool.
Karen: Yeah, the cover kind of looks like you randomly woke up and had a camera in your face. "GASP!"
But the outfit is cute. The spread is fascinating, and I love your outfit here. I kind of wish it was slightly bigger, but that's a minor quibble. Well done!
BB: I really like your Cover photo. The styling (dress especially) for me was so fabulous. I love that dress. Blue looks really good on you. The spread was okay. I'm just not too excited with that one. I think your face expression for those 2 photos were almost similar and I want to see a different side from you next time
Amanda: I disagree about the cover. That dress makes it look like... let's not go there. I also concur that we need more emotion from you.
Matt: I think both are very pretty and stunning. The one thing that i don't like about the cover is that your boob almost looks like it's about to pop out. But i love your face it's adorable. I have nothing wrong with the Spread i like it.
Nicki: The cover is bordering a costume malfunction. The spread is only okay. More emotion is necessary for you to last much longer.
Karen: The cover is reasonably strong, but it seems like you tend to always have the exact same pouty facial expression going on in every single photo, and that's definitely something you'll need to move away from.
The spread is a bit meh, and it could definitely use some touching up, as it's really dark. But the outfit and facial expression aren't bad, so it's not terrible or anything.
Amanda: I saw what you did here in your samples thread. You made these from scratch, and it takes guts to do that. I know I would have to if I were doing this shoot, but I highly doubt I'd make them as good as these. For your courage and taking a risk, I award you points. The only issue I see with that cover is that the "Rolling Stone" title is behind your head, when most magazines would have that over the image. Something to keep in mind if you attempt this again.
I see the magazine cover and suddenly had a nightmare of Rachel from Big Brother... you almost look like her and that's scary. These also aren't high-fashion shots exactly, but they're you and that helps. You're sending a message of who you are here more than anything, and apart from that there's really nothing wrong with either of these.
I again applaud you for your taking a huge risk here, and because of that alone you should have no concerns this week. Great work!
BB: I was really worried for you girl, I was thinking, will she do a Playboy, Maxim or FHM and the fact that you ome with this was such a full of relieve. The spread is fabulous. I love the pose. A little bit hoochie but the whole concept really save you. As for the cover, there are certain flaw (NECK, Mouth) but overall you really exceed my expetation
Matt: I love the risk for you. Both shoots are very sexual but they aren't playboy sex. Out of the two my favorite would be the magazine cover but i actually like both of them.
Nicki: I think this is an incredible comeback from next week. You're totally awesome for making these on your own, and I give you major props for that <3
Karen: Holy crap, I can't believe you made your own. I definitely couldn't tell. Also, The Clash are freakin' amazing (and English Civil War, no joke, once saved my life) so you get major props for that.
These photos are very good, and you're doing well at edging around the tramp factor, which is always important. Great work!
Amanda: This isn't bad, though the "FASHION" title on the cover covers you to the point that it distracts from you. I also think the jewelry is overdone, but I love that green dress. The spread is just okay for me... there's really nothing memorable about it. It's good, just forgettable.
BB: I'm not really excited as last week. I don't know why. I think the styling is okay. My problem is your looks. I didn't like the makeup, and the pose was kinda average for me. I think the spread is better than the cover and it might help you this week
Matt: I wish I could see more emotion in these but they are both beautiful but beautiful and plain. I'm going to agree with Amanda and say that the Fashion is in the way.
Nicki: There is A LOT going on in that cover, and it totally detracts from you. Not a fan. The spread is nice and classy though, good job on that!
Karen: The cover is a bit too cluttered to get a good look at you, and the facial expression just seems... off, to me. But the pose is neat and I like the outfit, so it's not too bad.
The spread, OMAGASH there is legit good photo quality! Finally! I like everything about it, even if it is somewhat unmemorable.
Amanda: I want to like the magazine cover, I really do. I like the makeup but it almost seems overdone. Your eyes, though, are awesome, though I'm not sure on the hair. It would get my attention and that's fine. It's not my favorite, but it's good enough. The spread... uh I'm not really sure. It's almost kind of trashy and sporty at the same time. I don't like your hair there, and the quality definitely seems off. I can't really say I like it, sorry. The cover is at least passable, so I hope you don't have anything to worry about.
BB: You look like a Barbie doll in the cover magazine and I really like it. I don't even know the language but this cover really stuck in my head. As for the Spread, it's bold, edgy and riskier but it really works for me. You have the attitude..
Matt: I'm going to agree with amanda on the Cover. I liked it at first glance but then the makeup just takes away from natural beauty. The spread is sort of awkward to me and it seems as if your trying to give yourslef a wedgie.
Nicki: I'm not a huge fan of either, and I'm waiting for something from you to compare to the greatness we saw in week 1. I think you look way too fake in the first one, and your hair is ugly in the spread. Sorry :/
Karen: I like the cover a lot. It's very mysterious and I love how the nails match the text.
The spread's pose is a little bit awkward, I think, and I'm not a huge fan of the hair. But the facial expression is unbelievably fierce, and that's great.
BB: I think both photos were so stylish. I love your new hair color. I think you look very strong for your Cover Mag. I see attitude in your photo. For you Spread, It's fun, vibrant and I can feel your energy girl. Good job
Amanda: That cover is FIERCE. I really like how the hat compliments your expression and outfit, and it overall gives a very strong, mature vibe - it's something older for you, yet not too old, and it looks awesome. The spread is just okay for me. Your eyes are closed and the radio is a bit strange. It's not bad though, and I don't think you should have a problem moving on to next round!
Matt: When i think of you i think of young and both of these show the youth in you. I like how in the cover it's a bit of youth mixed with adult and i like your pose and outfit. Great Job. The spread makes me think of fun, i wish your eyes were open and you were laughing or something but it's still good.
Nicki: Selena, I think you kicked ass this week. These are both fantastic shots. You're preserving your youth, yet looking elegant. Great job!
Karen: I think the magazine cover is one of the strongest I've ever seen. It works really well on a number of levels. Not a huge fan of the poor photo quality on the spread, and the facial expression is a bit mneh to me, but other than that it's not bad.
BB: I'm not as excited as last week, Shilpa. For your Cover, I think "Blake Lively" kinda distract us from you. But your pose this week really good. I think your style in the cover is really different from what we've see before. You look way more edgy here. For you spread, I wish you would have sharper you pose, maybe stretch you legs all the way so we can see your long legs flawlessly.
Matt: I love the cover. I didnt know Blake was there until i read BB's comment. I Like the pose and the dress. The spread is sort of plain but i like it.
Nicki: I'm hesitant to like the cover, because it just is a weird dress. I think your spread is pretty good though!
Karen: The face and hair are a little too Morticia Addams for me, but I think the dress is interesting, and the pose is very powerful.
I really like the magazine spread, but I wish that it didn't have the words on it. That's not enough of a detraction to make me hate it, though.
Welcome to your Third Judging session. I don't waste any more time since I knew a lot of you dying to find out the result..
Let see your photo this week
Amanda: I'm not really fond of either of these. The pose on the cover is really awkward to the point that it looks painful, and there's too much going on around you. The spread looks lower-quality and you come across as a cyborg. I really don't know how good your chances are this week given these
BB: I really like the Cover.. I think you look energetic.. Yes of course I want some Choco Neck from you but for me, the styling in this Cover is good enough. I love the make up, hairstyles and even the dress though we can't see it completely. I'm not really excited with the spread. I love your face but the styling didn't work for me.
Matt: I love the cover. The smile and everything about it. I don't like the spread it doesnt look model like at all. But i know you'll do well.
Nicki: I quite enjoy the poses of both, but not the layout of either.
Karen: I like the magazine cover. It's very fresh and cute, even if the pose is a tad awkward. The spread, however, is a bit sci-fi and the photo quality is a little too blurry for my tastes. Overall, I'm fairly impressed.
BB: I think your cover is so beautiful. Very alive and once again your lips; really sexy and beautiful. And your spread, i'm not sure about this one. Your eyes were close and the angle is a little bit off. Even the pose a little bit awkward for me.
Amanda: That cover is very memorable but like last time too zoomed in. Your spread is iffy given the pose and the arm and the expression...
Matt: I like both of these. The Cover is very different and very beautiful. The spread is a bit plan but very model like.
Nicki: I absolutely LOVE the cover, but the spread is mediocre at best.
Karen: I'm pretty much in the same boat as everybody else. I think that the cover is beautiful, and very artistic, but the pose in the spread really doesn't do you any favors and hides your face, which is definitely a no-no.
Amanda: The magazine cover is good, but that dress looks to be a bit too much for me and your expression is a bit too vacant. The spread seems grainy, but after that it's pretty good. I can't find anything wrong with it, but I can't find anything that sticks out to me, either. Overall, these two are just okay.
BB: The styling for the Cover one a little bit messy.. Look 'heavy' on you but I love the whole concept. You face should be more stronger. I knew you can do better than this. As for the Spread, I think it is a good shot. You look very flirty and innocent at the same time. I love the concept.
Matt: The cover = beautiful but the only thing i dont like is your mouth it's shaped weird but other than that its great. The spread is very simple and i like that. I love the hair and the pose.
Nicki: I'm not a huge fan of the cover because you look spaced out. I do like the spread, though. Good job on that! \
Karen: It's true, you do look kind of bored in the cover, but everything else in the photo is simply astounding.
The spread, ech, I hate the quality. In fact, I've hated on the quality of every spread this round, so I'm just going to stop saying that, because apparently this is just a universal thing with spreads or something. Anyway, the pose is good, but the facial expression definitely puts me in the mind of zombies, and that's never a good thing unless you're modelling for a Halloween photoshoot.
Amanda: I'm not completely sure about either of them. The cover is kind of plain and generic, and your expression needs work. This is the kind of cover I wouldn't be interested to find out who is on it, since it's so unmemorable and not very striking, and it's also a bit cluttered. I do like your hair, though.
The spread is definitely something very, very different, and since it's a risk it's more apt to win points with me. I again like your hair, but you almost look like a mime in a clown's outfit. Those socks are kind of iffy, and it just seems weird in general. I love the setting though, as it's like you're telling a story, showing emotion. I like it, but don't love it since it's just kind of weird for me. I do want you to stay around, though, so good luck and hope you do
BB: You were lucky this isn't a stress week, so I don't mind the extension. As for the Cover, I really like it. I think you look very soft, sweet and vulnerable. As for the spread, your look was really different than the Cover one, In this one, you are edgier and bolder. The styling kinda off to me.. The combination didn't work for me, but overall you did good
Matt: Not a fan of the cover. Your face looks kind of dead and tired. The Spread i like a lot. It's very artistic and it's something that catches my eye and will be something I remember.
Nicki: Not a fan of the cover either, but the spread is very cool.
Karen: Yeah, the cover kind of looks like you randomly woke up and had a camera in your face. "GASP!"
But the outfit is cute. The spread is fascinating, and I love your outfit here. I kind of wish it was slightly bigger, but that's a minor quibble. Well done!
BB: I really like your Cover photo. The styling (dress especially) for me was so fabulous. I love that dress. Blue looks really good on you. The spread was okay. I'm just not too excited with that one. I think your face expression for those 2 photos were almost similar and I want to see a different side from you next time
Amanda: I disagree about the cover. That dress makes it look like... let's not go there. I also concur that we need more emotion from you.
Matt: I think both are very pretty and stunning. The one thing that i don't like about the cover is that your boob almost looks like it's about to pop out. But i love your face it's adorable. I have nothing wrong with the Spread i like it.
Nicki: The cover is bordering a costume malfunction. The spread is only okay. More emotion is necessary for you to last much longer.
Karen: The cover is reasonably strong, but it seems like you tend to always have the exact same pouty facial expression going on in every single photo, and that's definitely something you'll need to move away from.
The spread is a bit meh, and it could definitely use some touching up, as it's really dark. But the outfit and facial expression aren't bad, so it's not terrible or anything.
Amanda: I saw what you did here in your samples thread. You made these from scratch, and it takes guts to do that. I know I would have to if I were doing this shoot, but I highly doubt I'd make them as good as these. For your courage and taking a risk, I award you points. The only issue I see with that cover is that the "Rolling Stone" title is behind your head, when most magazines would have that over the image. Something to keep in mind if you attempt this again.
I see the magazine cover and suddenly had a nightmare of Rachel from Big Brother... you almost look like her and that's scary. These also aren't high-fashion shots exactly, but they're you and that helps. You're sending a message of who you are here more than anything, and apart from that there's really nothing wrong with either of these.
I again applaud you for your taking a huge risk here, and because of that alone you should have no concerns this week. Great work!
BB: I was really worried for you girl, I was thinking, will she do a Playboy, Maxim or FHM and the fact that you ome with this was such a full of relieve. The spread is fabulous. I love the pose. A little bit hoochie but the whole concept really save you. As for the cover, there are certain flaw (NECK, Mouth) but overall you really exceed my expetation
Matt: I love the risk for you. Both shoots are very sexual but they aren't playboy sex. Out of the two my favorite would be the magazine cover but i actually like both of them.
Nicki: I think this is an incredible comeback from next week. You're totally awesome for making these on your own, and I give you major props for that <3
Karen: Holy crap, I can't believe you made your own. I definitely couldn't tell. Also, The Clash are freakin' amazing (and English Civil War, no joke, once saved my life) so you get major props for that.
These photos are very good, and you're doing well at edging around the tramp factor, which is always important. Great work!
Amanda: This isn't bad, though the "FASHION" title on the cover covers you to the point that it distracts from you. I also think the jewelry is overdone, but I love that green dress. The spread is just okay for me... there's really nothing memorable about it. It's good, just forgettable.
BB: I'm not really excited as last week. I don't know why. I think the styling is okay. My problem is your looks. I didn't like the makeup, and the pose was kinda average for me. I think the spread is better than the cover and it might help you this week
Matt: I wish I could see more emotion in these but they are both beautiful but beautiful and plain. I'm going to agree with Amanda and say that the Fashion is in the way.
Nicki: There is A LOT going on in that cover, and it totally detracts from you. Not a fan. The spread is nice and classy though, good job on that!
Karen: The cover is a bit too cluttered to get a good look at you, and the facial expression just seems... off, to me. But the pose is neat and I like the outfit, so it's not too bad.
The spread, OMAGASH there is legit good photo quality! Finally! I like everything about it, even if it is somewhat unmemorable.
Amanda: I want to like the magazine cover, I really do. I like the makeup but it almost seems overdone. Your eyes, though, are awesome, though I'm not sure on the hair. It would get my attention and that's fine. It's not my favorite, but it's good enough. The spread... uh I'm not really sure. It's almost kind of trashy and sporty at the same time. I don't like your hair there, and the quality definitely seems off. I can't really say I like it, sorry. The cover is at least passable, so I hope you don't have anything to worry about.
BB: You look like a Barbie doll in the cover magazine and I really like it. I don't even know the language but this cover really stuck in my head. As for the Spread, it's bold, edgy and riskier but it really works for me. You have the attitude..
Matt: I'm going to agree with amanda on the Cover. I liked it at first glance but then the makeup just takes away from natural beauty. The spread is sort of awkward to me and it seems as if your trying to give yourslef a wedgie.
Nicki: I'm not a huge fan of either, and I'm waiting for something from you to compare to the greatness we saw in week 1. I think you look way too fake in the first one, and your hair is ugly in the spread. Sorry :/
Karen: I like the cover a lot. It's very mysterious and I love how the nails match the text.
The spread's pose is a little bit awkward, I think, and I'm not a huge fan of the hair. But the facial expression is unbelievably fierce, and that's great.
BB: I think both photos were so stylish. I love your new hair color. I think you look very strong for your Cover Mag. I see attitude in your photo. For you Spread, It's fun, vibrant and I can feel your energy girl. Good job
Amanda: That cover is FIERCE. I really like how the hat compliments your expression and outfit, and it overall gives a very strong, mature vibe - it's something older for you, yet not too old, and it looks awesome. The spread is just okay for me. Your eyes are closed and the radio is a bit strange. It's not bad though, and I don't think you should have a problem moving on to next round!
Matt: When i think of you i think of young and both of these show the youth in you. I like how in the cover it's a bit of youth mixed with adult and i like your pose and outfit. Great Job. The spread makes me think of fun, i wish your eyes were open and you were laughing or something but it's still good.
Nicki: Selena, I think you kicked ass this week. These are both fantastic shots. You're preserving your youth, yet looking elegant. Great job!
Karen: I think the magazine cover is one of the strongest I've ever seen. It works really well on a number of levels. Not a huge fan of the poor photo quality on the spread, and the facial expression is a bit mneh to me, but other than that it's not bad.
BB: I'm not as excited as last week, Shilpa. For your Cover, I think "Blake Lively" kinda distract us from you. But your pose this week really good. I think your style in the cover is really different from what we've see before. You look way more edgy here. For you spread, I wish you would have sharper you pose, maybe stretch you legs all the way so we can see your long legs flawlessly.
Matt: I love the cover. I didnt know Blake was there until i read BB's comment. I Like the pose and the dress. The spread is sort of plain but i like it.
Nicki: I'm hesitant to like the cover, because it just is a weird dress. I think your spread is pretty good though!
Karen: The face and hair are a little too Morticia Addams for me, but I think the dress is interesting, and the pose is very powerful.
I really like the magazine spread, but I wish that it didn't have the words on it. That's not enough of a detraction to make me hate it, though.
